Spirit Cruises January 2023 Leaderboard

SF Weekly Taste-Tests Marshmallow, PB&J Vodka So We Don't Have To

by The Drink Nation on Apr 30, 2012 in Liquor
SF Weekly Taste-Tests Marshmallow, PB&J Vodka So We Don't Have To

Wanted to shout out thanks to the good cocktailians at SF Weekly, who dedicated a day (and a whole lot of poor taste buds) to trying out six of the ickiest-sounding flavored vodkas on the market today. Their conclusion? These spirits tastes about as good as they sound – which is to say, not very.

Put to the test of scent and nose are creations like Smirnoff Fluffed Marshmallow, Pinnacle Cotton Candy and Van Gogh Peanut Butter & Jelly vodkas, among other abominations. Reading the capsule reviews really makes you glad they’re taking this one for the team. For example, regarding Pinnacle Cookie Dough:

Without indulging in histrionics, SFoodie will say that this is the most disgusting thing we've put in our mouth since our last encounter with silkworm larvae. The flavor is dominated by a fierce grain-alcohol burn, and then comes a weird finish, as if we have been snorting detergent powder. At this point in the tasting, the marshmallow vodka begins to seem like the classiest drink in the bunch.

Head over to read the rest, because a) the writing is pretty funny and b) you gotta mark these down so that next time you’re standing in the liquor store aisle, eyes glazed over from the ridiculous amount of choices, you know which ones to avoid.

Recent Articles
spacer

Feedback

How are we doing? Tell us what you like or don't like and how we can improve. We would love to hear your thoughts!

*Name:
*E-mail:
*Suggestions:
 
Mural City Cellars: Local Winery Spotlight on Philly's Winery That's Community Focused

Mural City Cellars: Local Winery Spotlight on Philly's Winery That's Community Focused

This family-friendly neighborhood winery positions itself as a welcoming place for all in the community...read more ›

by Robin Shreeves May 5, 2026
First 'World Class Top 15 Bartender' from Philadelphia: Behind the Bar with Alexis Ortega

First 'World Class Top 15 Bartender' from Philadelphia: Behind the Bar with Alexis Ortega

This time on Behind the Bar, we interview bartender Alexis Ortega about his experience in the industry, what h...read more ›

by Drink Philly Apr 26, 2026
The Drink Nation Presents: The Home Bar Project

The Drink Nation Presents: The Home Bar Project

Have you ever dreamed of having an amazing home bar, filled with bottles you actually use and the tools you need to execute a fine crafted cocktail? E...read more ›

by The Drink Nation Nov 14, 2014
SPONSORED
Spirit Cruises January 2023 Desktop Bottom Rectangle 1
Philly Hosts U.S. Bartenders' Guild Bar Summit, Featuring William H. Macy, Danny Childs, & More

Philly Hosts U.S. Bartenders' Guild Bar Summit, Featuring William H. Macy, Danny Childs, & More

William H. Macy is keynoting the US Bartenders' Guild Bar Summit in Philly this month...read more ›

by Michelle Cryder Apr 21, 2026
Local Winery Spotlight: Vox Vineti Wines

Local Winery Spotlight: Vox Vineti Wines

Ed Lazzerini says his goal is clear - to make world class wine in Pennsylvania. From the taste of it, he is well on his way. ...read more ›

by Drink Philly Nov 21, 2020
Meadowbrook Winery: Local Winery Spotlight on NJ's Stunning New Tasting Room

Meadowbrook Winery: Local Winery Spotlight on NJ's Stunning New Tasting Room

One of New Jersey's newest wineries is in Oldwick, New Jersey and has just five grape varieties planted in its...read more ›

by Robin Shreeves Mar 2, 2026
13th Annual Philly Bierfest Returns with Over 75 Beers, Arm Wrestling, Axe Throwing, Music, & More, Feb 28

13th Annual Philly Bierfest Returns with Over 75 Beers, Arm Wrestling, Axe Throwing, Music, & More, Feb 28

The German Society of Pennsylvania's 13th Annual Bierfest returns February 28 with a selection of over 50 Germ...read more ›

by Michelle Cryder Feb 19, 2026
Cocktails Quarterly: Best Bars to Drink in Philly, Winter 2026

Cocktails Quarterly: Best Bars to Drink in Philly, Winter 2026

Welcome to Cocktails Quarterly - Drink Philly's newest segment showcasing the best bars (new and old) where you should be getting a drink this Winter...read more ›

by Alisha Miranda Feb 3, 2026
The Best Mocktails, Zero Proof, & Non-Alcoholic Drinks in Philadelphia, 2026

The Best Mocktails, Zero Proof, & Non-Alcoholic Drinks in Philadelphia, 2026

Giving your liver a break in the new year, or just looking for something a little different? We've got your 20...read more ›

by Michelle Cryder Jan 11, 2026
Velvet Whip: Inside Look at the New Mixed Arts Speakeasy & Performance Space

Velvet Whip: Inside Look at the New Mixed Arts Speakeasy & Performance Space

This once hidden gem has opened to the public, and is where cocktails and creativity meet...read more ›

by Michelle Cryder Nov 16, 2025
SPONSORED
View all Articles

Sign up to get weekly drinking news, bar reviews, events and more sent directly to your inbox!

Close